

Ashley won't get her a new one since Hanna purposefully destroyed the old one. In the morning, Hanna argues with her mom about getting a replacement phone.

Just then, a car pulls up and Jenna and Toby emerge, Jenna's eye bandaged post-surgery. Emily questions if Duncan is just a random guy Alison flirted with, but Spencer is sure Ali wouldn't have wasted time flirting while trying to track down " A." Aria decides to call him. Aria shows Spencer Duncan's number and tells her he met Vivian in a bookstore a few doors down from the creepy doll hospital Jonah sent them to. He doesn't know Alison/Vivian is dead because he has been in Florida the past year.

She told him she was a friend of Vivian's and hasn't seen her since she gave her the coat. Sitting outside Lucky Leon's, Aria tells the others about Duncan Albert, the boy who thought she was Vivian at the end of the previous episode.
